Skip to content
ACE FORGE HVAC — Go-green solution provider

Engineer’s note

PEXFit vs Copper: Installation Time and Leak Risk

Multilayer PEX-AL-PEX line sets versus copper: where the joints are, what each system demands of the installer, and the code question to settle first.

· 6 min read

“Copper or plastic?” is the wrong opening question for a line-set decision, because it compares materials when the thing that fails is a joint. A copper line set and a multilayer line set carry the same refrigerant between the same two boxes. What differs is how many times somebody has to make a connection, what tooling that connection needs, and whether the authority having jurisdiction will accept it.

Those three questions are answerable. Material preference is not.

What a multilayer line set actually is

The pipe in a PEXFit system is a five-layer composite: an inner layer of cross-linked polyethylene, an adhesive layer, an aluminium layer, an adhesive layer, and an outer layer of cross-linked polyethylene. The aluminium is continuous and laser-welded along its seam.

That construction matters for two reasons that are mechanical rather than promotional:

  • The aluminium layer is a barrier. A polymer-only tube is permeable to oxygen and to refrigerant over time. The metal layer is what stops that diffusion, which is why PEX-AL-PEX behaves differently from plain PEX.
  • The pipe is formable by hand. A composite tube can be bent to a radius without a bender and without annealing, which removes a tool and a hot-work step from the job.

Available sizes cover 12, 16, 20 and 25 mm tube, with fittings in compression, union, straight, elbow and solder styles. The intended envelope is mini-split and multi-split systems from 9,000 to 36,000 BTU, plus light commercial A/C up to 5 ton.

Where leakage actually happens

Count the joints. That is the honest way to compare two line-set systems.

Joint type How it seals What it depends on
Brazed copper Filler metal, capillary action Purge gas, torch control, operator skill
Flared copper Mechanical deformation of the tube Flare angle, cone condition, torque
Compression on composite Nut, compression ring, insert, O-ring Cut squareness, reaming, insert seating, torque

Every one of those is a competent connection when it is done correctly, and every one of them fails when a step is skipped. The failure modes differ:

  • A bad braze leaks at the joint face, or worse, sends oxide scale into the circuit because nobody purged with nitrogen. The leak you find is not always the damage you caused.
  • A bad flare cracks at the cone, or holds at commissioning and weeps a season later when the system sees its first cold night.
  • A bad compression joint is usually traced to a burr left by the cutter, an insert that was not pushed to the shoulder, or an O-ring nicked on the way in. These are installation-discipline failures, not material failures — which is good news, because discipline can be trained and inspected.

The multilayer system’s structural advantage is arithmetic: a bend replaces an elbow, and a fitting replaces a braze. Fewer connections means fewer opportunities for any of the three failure modes above.

That advantage is real but conditional. A compression joint installed without a reamer and without a torque habit is not safer than a braze; it is just newer.

What drives installation time

Time comparisons between line-set systems usually get made at the level of “no torch, therefore faster”. That is directionally right and practically incomplete. Here is what actually moves the clock:

Saved:

  • No brazing, so no torch, no nitrogen purge rig, no fire watch, and no hot-work permit on occupied sites.
  • No bender for elbows: the tube is formed by hand.
  • Lighter coils, easier in a lift or on a ladder.
  • Connections can be made in sequence with hand tools instead of a torch and a regulator.

Added:

  • Cutting square and reaming to a bevel is now a required step, not an optional courtesy.
  • Each joint needs the nut and compression ring pre-loaded in the right order before the fitting goes on.
  • The insert must seat to the shoulder without damaging the O-ring.
  • Two tightening steps with a wrench, at the right torque.

The net effect is that a multilayer system shifts labour from hot work by a specialist to repeatable steps by a technician. Whether that is faster on your job depends on your crew’s brazing speed and on whether hot-work permits are a bottleneck. On an occupied commercial site in winter, the permit is usually the bottleneck, not the torch.

The question to settle before you buy anything

Composite refrigerant piping is not accepted everywhere. Acceptance is a code matter, and code is local.

In Canada, refrigeration systems are subject to the mechanical refrigeration code and to provincial or territorial adoption of it, and refrigerant handling itself is regulated. Before specifying any line-set material, confirm with the authority having jurisdiction that the material and the joining method are accepted for the application and the refrigerant in use, and confirm that the work will be performed by qualified personnel.

This is not a formality to be handled after the purchase order. It is the first question, and it is the one that occasionally ends the evaluation — better to learn that from the AHJ than from an inspector on commissioning day.

The installation sequence

The sequence below is the one our fitting system is designed around. It is worth reading even if you choose another product, because the discipline it enforces is the same discipline that keeps any compression joint dry.

  1. Cut the pipe vertically and squarely with a pipe cutter.
  2. Round and bevel the cut end with a reamer. Metal and plastic reamers are available for 12, 16, 20 and 25 mm tube.
  3. Select the fitting for the tube size. Place the nut and the compression ring onto the pipe.
  4. Install the fitting onto the air-conditioning valves.
  5. Push the insert into the pipe up to the shoulder, taking care not to damage the O-ring.
  6. Tighten the fitting with a wrench.
  7. Tighten the nut with a wrench.
  8. Fit the insulation sleeve.

Two application scenarios cover most mini-split work: an outdoor unit with a screw valve, and an outdoor unit with a copper tube outlet.

The tools are a metal pipe cutter and a reamer. That is the whole kit, and it is the reason the method travels well to sites where a torch is unwelcome.

On cost

Cost comparisons in this category are usually asserted and rarely documented, so treat any headline figure — ours included if we ever publish one — as unverified until it is run against your own numbers. What is defensible is the structure: material cost per metre, fitting count, and labour hours per joint. Put your own labour rate against the joint count in the table above and the comparison becomes yours rather than a supplier’s.

What to put in the submittal

A line-set submittal should carry the material and construction, the tube sizes and the fitting range, the pressure and temperature ratings of the fittings, the joining method with the tooling specified, the insulation, the acceptance basis from the AHJ, and the commissioning procedure — evacuation, pressure test and leak test — that applies to the whole circuit.

Our PEXFit family page lists the construction, the tube sizes, the fitting range and the application envelope we build to. If the system you are connecting is a mini-split, the A-C coil family and the side-discharge condensing units describe the indoor and outdoor halves that these line sets are normally matched to, and the installation parts overview shows the rest of the connection kit.

Part of a series: this article sits inside the PEXFit Multilayer Pipe installation guide — the installation guide — construction, fitting range, the eight-step sequence and the code question.